| POINTS | Juan Dixon | Calvert Hall (MD) | ’96 | 47 |
| FIELD GOALS | Juan Dixon | Calvert Hall (MD) | ’96 | 17 |
| FIELD GOAL % | Alvin Brown | Gonzaga (DC) | ’96 | 80% |
| 3 POINT SHOTS | Jack Leasure | McQuaid (NY) | ’03 | 10 |
| FREE THROW ATTEMPTS | Adrian Mills | Paul VI (VA) | ’06 | 21 |
| FREE THROWS MADE | Mark Karcher | St. Frances | ‘95 | 16 |
| Vernon Alonzo | Longwood | ’98 | 16 | |
| FREE THROW PERCENTAGE | Brian Johnson | Mt. St. Joseph (NY) | ‘03 | 1 |
| REBOUNDS | Moses Brown | Archbishop Molloy (NY) | ’16 | 23 |
| ASSISTS | Shammgod Wells | LaSalle (NY) | ’94 | 14 |
| BLOCKS | Jeff Whitey | Horizon (CA) | ‘06 | 12 |
| Talib Zanna | McNamara (MD) | ’07 | 12 |
| POINTS | Josh Hart | Sidwell Friends (MD) | ‘12 | 98 |
| FIELD GOALS | Juan Dixon | Calvert Hall (MD) | ‘96 | 32 |
| FIELD GOAL % | Alvin Brown | Gonzaga (DC) | ‘96 | 65.9% |
| 3 POINT SHOTS | Jack Leasure | McQuaid (NY) | ‘03 | 18 |
| FREE THROW ATTEMPTS | Marquis Carter | Horizon (CA) | ‘06 | 34 |
| AdrianMills | Paul VI | ‘06 | 34 | |
| FREE THROWS MADE | Mark Karcher | St. Frances | ‘95 | 26 |
| Marquis Carter | Horizon (CA) | ‘06 | 26 | |
| FREE THROW PERCENTAGE | Brian Johnson | Mt. St. Joseph (MD) | ‘03 | 1 |
| REBOUNDS | Moses Brown | Archbishop Molloy (NY) | ‘16 | 47 |
| ASSISTS | Shammgod Wells | LaSalle | ‘94 | 37 |
| BLOCKS | Jeff Withey | Horizon (CA) | ‘06 | 25 |
| POINTS | Bishop Loughlin v. Towson Catholic | ‘07 | 104 |
| FIELD GOALS | Bishop Loughlin v. Towson Catholic | ‘07 | 41 |
| FIELD GOAL % | Gonzaga v. Bishop Loughlin | ‘96 | 56% |
| 3 POINT GOALS | McQuaid (NY) | ‘03 | 12 |
| FREE THROW ATTEMPTS | St. Frances v. St. Raymond | ‘95 | 61 |
| FREE THROWS MADE | St. Frances v. St. Raymond | ‘95 | 42 |
| FREE THROW % | Mt. St. Joseph v. McQuaid Jesuit | ‘03 | 94% |
| FEWEST POINTS ALLOWED | LaSalle v. Gonzaga | ‘94 | 27 |
| REBOUNDS | Pallotti v. Dunbar | '95 | 40 |
| OFFENSIVE REBOUNDS | Gonzaga v. Dunbar | ‘95 | 18 |
| LONGEST GAME | Bullis (MD) v. Longwood (NY) | ‘98 | 4 OT |
| VICTORY MARGIN | Bishop Loughlin v. Towson Catholic | ‘07 | 42 |
| POINTS | St. Raymond (NY) | ‘94 | 226 |
| FIELD GOALS | St. Frances/DeMatha | ‘95/‘94 | 73 |
| FIELD GOAL % | Gonzaga | ‘96 | 50.2% |
| FREE THROW ATTEMPTS | St. Frances | ‘95 | 112 |
| FREE THROWS MADE | St. Frances | ‘95 | 68 |
| FREE THROW % | Mt. St. Joseph | ‘03 | 89% |
| 3 POINT GOALS | McQuaid (NY) | ’03 | 24 |
| FEWEST POINTS ALLOWED | LaSalle (NY) | ‘94 | 116 |
| REBOUNDS | St. Thomas Aquinas (FL) | ‘95 | 88 |
| OFFENSIVE REBOUNDS | Gonzaga | ‘95 | 36 |